Register

NEW DVD AND CINEMA REVIEWS NEW

DVD review: Clone Hunter

article thumbnail

Often, sci-fi and low budget indie productions go together about as well as chocolate and onions. The high budget demands on special effects eventually hamper the entire story. Clone Hunter is indeed  [ ... ]


What to make of the ending to Inception?

article thumbnail

So far, my favorite film this year is Christopher Nolanís Inception. Not only does it deliver all the action and thrills expected of a big budget summer blockbuster, but it has inspired endl [ ... ]


DVD Review: The White Ribbon

article thumbnail

The White Ribbon is a drama starring Christian Freidl, Ulrich Turkl and Burghart Klaussner. Directed by Michael Haneke.

There is something wrong here. In a seemingly quaint German village pre-WW1, [ ... ]


DVD Review: Shutter Island

article thumbnail

The film begins on an ominous note. Eerie strings play as the film fades to white. Soon, a ship appears out of the fog. Cut to a gumshoe, looking and speaking as if he has stepped straight out of a [ ... ]


DVD Review: The White Ribbon PDF Print E-mail
Written by Administrator   
Wednesday, 21 July 2010 12:48
ImageThe White Ribbon is a drama starring Christian Freidl, Ulrich Turkl and Burghart Klaussner. Directed by Michael Haneke.

There is something wrong here. In a seemingly quaint German village pre-WW1, one unpleasant event occurs after another and no one is quite sure why.

There is a seeming sense of order in the village. It is run by a baron who owns most of the land and is the primary employer. There is a pastor who is the moral authoritarian in the village, along with a doctor and a young schoolteacher who is smitten with a young woman from a nearby village (he narrates the story years later).

Like Hanekeís most notable films (Funny Games; Cache), a sense of perfect order is upset by a strange, unexplainable occurrence which slowly spreads through the formally ideal sense of order like a cancer, until it destroys what once was.
It all starts when a wire trips the horse being ridden by the doctor, leading to the horse being destroyed and the doctor being severely injured. Other strange and sinister events soon follow:
  • Someone opens a window near a newborn baby, exposing it to the cold.
  • The baronís son is found tied and beaten.
  • A barn is burned to the ground.
  • A local farmer hangs himself (or does he?)
  • The pastorís pet bird is stabbed to death
  • A midwifeís child (who suffers from Downs Syndrome) is found beaten as well (a message near him suggests divine punishment).

An increasing sense of unease, dread and helplessness soon permeates the village. There is no uniform plan on how to handle the situation or to uncover the culprits. The baronís wife flees to Italy. The pastor, on the other hand, turns even more strict on his children (the white ribbon of the title refers to the ribbon he forces his children to wear to remind them to be pure and chaste). He will not spare the rod, or public humiliation, in order to enforce his will. 

It soon falls on the schoolteacher to unravel the mystery. What he discovers is disturbing, yet he must bring it to the town leaders. Will they believe what he uncovers? More importantly, will they accept it?

Like most of Hanekeís films, there is a quiet distance, or coldness, in his work than can be off-putting.  Furthermore, his mysteries tend never to be solved completely. He rarely explains his mysteries, for the purpose of them is not the answer, but how his characters react to the mystery, how it changes them and the ìglass houseî world they have established

Other reviews have referred to the film that is an allegory, or ominously announces the arrival of Nazi Germany. No Haneke film is that simple. There are multiple potential answers. Is the violence a product of a repressive society hidden under an ideal faÁade? Did one act of malevolence cause the town leaders to overreact and create a backlash, thus destroying their village in the name of saving it? Does telling someone they are evil actually instead cause them to be evil?

Though perhaps too cold and quiet at times (and lacking a bit of the eerie discomfort created by Cache), The White Ribbon is another strong, challenging work by one of todayís leading directors. There are numerous potential answers to the mysteries he creates, yet he knows life is too complicated for a pat answer every time.

blog comments powered by Disqus
 

twitter_logo

SUBSCRIBE to the INDIE FILM KIOSK MINI CATALOG for valuable news, coupons and discounts! Get the pdf catalog downloaded to your computer and into your Itunes or other xml/rss feed reader:

Subscribe in a reader

Lifesize Entertainment - The Indie Film Kiosk Mini Catalog - The Indie Film Kiosk Mini Catalog
subscribe with Itunes!
Documents


Get the Walter Ego Podcast!
Image
edward flynn - Walter-Ego-Critic-at-Large - Walter-Ego-Critic-at-Large
subscribe with Itunes!

Sponsored Links

Top Ten Lists PICK

Top Ten Mind Mess Films
In the wake of Inception, I thought it might be fun to create a list of 10 of the best mind mess movies. All of these films are very good, with some masterpieces. What they have in common is a tendency to question re
Top Ten Worst Endings
To quote David St. Hubbins of
Top 10 Rules for Horror Movies
As one who has seen way too many hor
Dennis Hopper's Top 5 Performances
Dennis Hopper, in memoriam:
<

FROM THE NEWS WIRE! FRESH

  • Like Father, Like Son: Cannes Review

    17 May 2013 | 6:40 pm

    Japanese director Kore-eda Hirokazu returns to the theme of children living apart from their families.read more

    Read more...
  • Best Buy Selling 4K TVs in 700 Stores

    17 May 2013 | 3:04 pm

    Best Buy Co., beginning May 19, will start selling Sony’s 4K ultra high definition televisions in about 700 Best Buy and Magnolia stores nationwide, according to a company tweet. 4K monitors offer four times the resolution (8.3 million vs. 2.1[…]

    Read more...
  • Fox Releasing 23 Classic Films For First Time on DVD

    17 May 2013 | 10:21 am

    Twentieth Century Fox Home Entertainment will release 23 movies on DVD for the first time at major retailers from its Fox Cinema Archives collection over the course of the next five weeks. Launched in 2012, Fox Cinema Archives includes more[…]

    Read more...
  • The Past: Cannes Review

    17 May 2013 | 7:26 am

    Berenice Bejo shines in a superbly lensed in competition drama from "A Separation's" Asghar Faradi.read more

    Read more...
  • New Releases: May 21, 2013

    17 May 2013 | 4:49 am

    Theatrical, Direct-to-Video and TV Movies Title Formats Studio Beautiful Creatures DVD, Blu-ray Warner The Last Stand DVD, Blu-ray Lionsgate Parker DVD, Blu-ray Sony Pictures Side Effects DVD, Blu-ray Universal Stand Up Guys DVD, Blu-ray Lionsgate Lego Batman: The Movie: DC[…]

    Read more...
  • A Touch of Sin: Cannes Review

    16 May 2013 | 5:54 pm

    China returns to the Cannes competition with Jia Zhang-ke's sobering view of festering discontent as the gap between the country's rich and poor expands.read more

    Read more...
  • Coinstar CEO: More Discs, Blu-ray to Lift Redbox

    16 May 2013 | 4:21 pm

    Redbox is becoming more attuned to consumer rental patterns, expects Blu-ray Discs to continue growing as a part of overall revenue and still anticipates overall rentals to increase 5% to 10% annually during the next three years, J. Scott Di[…]

    Read more...
  • Paramount Picks Up Rights to ‘Ghost Team One’

    15 May 2013 | 10:20 pm

    Paramount Home Media Distribution has picked up the worldwide distribution rights to the horror comedy Ghost Team One. The independent film — produced by Flying Monkeys Entertainment and Foresight Entertainment — follows two roommates trying to impress a girl, and[…]

    Read more...
  • HBO Home Entertainment Launches ‘True Blood’ Contest

    15 May 2013 | 10:08 pm

    HBO Home Entertainment is giving “True Blood” fans a chance to win autographed copies of the fifth season, out on disc May 21. Through May 17, fans can enter missing words from a “Psalm of Lilith” (#fillintheblood) via the show’s[…]

    Read more...
  • Redbox Instant Comes to LG TVs

    15 May 2013 | 9:54 pm

    LG Electronics’ latest connected HDTVs now offer the Redbox Instant application, joining Xbox 360, Apple devices and Samsung Blu-ray Disc players among other consumers electronics to carry the service. Google TV and Vizio are the next consumer electronics devices expected[…]

    Read more...
  • 'Safe Haven' Secures Top Sales Spot; 'Jack Reacher' Tops Rentals, Blu-ray Sales

    15 May 2013 | 9:00 pm

    Two recent theatrical hits, both new on disc, bowed in the top spots on the national home video sales charts the week ended May 12. On the Nielsen VideoScan First Alert chart, which tracks overall disc sales, the romantic drama[…]

    Read more...
  • Top 20 Blu-ray Market Share for the Week Ended 05/12/13

    15 May 2013 | 7:41 pm

    Rank Title Studio Share* 1 Star Trek Paramount 68.82% 2 Superman Unbound Warner 61.85% 3 The Avengers Disney/Marvel 48.61% 4 Jack Reacher Paramount 48.61% 5 Les Misérables Universal 47.01% 6 The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey Warner 42.68% 7 Django Unchained[…]

    Read more...
  • Top 20 Selling Blu-ray Discs for the Week Ended 05/12/13

    15 May 2013 | 7:39 pm

    Rank Title Studio Index* 1 Jack Reacher Paramount 100.00 2 Safe Haven Fox 89.59 3 Mama Universal 38.67 4 Silver Linings Playbook Anchor Bay 36.78 5 Superman Unbound Warner 25.92 6 Django Unchained Anchor Bay 23.09 7 Les Misérables Universal[…]

    Read more...
  • Top 20 Rentals for the Week Ended 05/12/13

    15 May 2013 | 7:38 pm

    This Week's Rank Last Week's Rank Title Street Date Studio Genre Days Since Release Box Office (Millions) 1 New Jack Reacher 5/7/13 Paramount Action 5 $80.07 2 1 Silver Linings Playbook 4/30/13 Anchor Bay Comedy 12 $131.96 3 2 The[…]

    Read more...
  • Top 20 Sellers for the Week Ended 05/12/13

    15 May 2013 | 7:34 pm

    This Week's Rank Last Week's Rank Title Street Date Studio Genre Weeks on Chart  Box Office (millions) Blu-ray Share for Title Index* 3D%† 1 New Safe Haven 5/7/13 Fox Romance 1 $71.29 29% 100.00 - 2 New Jack Reacher 5/7/13[…]

    Read more...